Sunday, July 26, 2009

The Passing of an Era

Yesterday I heard on the news that Harry Patch, the last veteran from the First World War and the last to have experienced at first hand the horrors of Trench Warfare, had passed away, scarcely a week after Henry Allingham, the oldest man in Europe and also penultimate World War one survivor, also passed away.
It seemed a moment to reflect on the significance of this. No Briton now survives who actually fought in the First World War. ( I'm uncertain if there are any survivors from other countries). As far as we as a nation are concerned the experience of fighting in that war is now outside living memory. What a horror story this was, by all accounts, and all for what? There wasn't the obvious moral crusade in fighting the evils of Naziism as in the Second World War. The Great War always seemed like an overdue longed-for 'punch up' between rather arrogant public schoolboys, each trying to prove who was the best and the strongest. It was a show-trial of rival national strengths.
True, Britain entered the war as Germany violated Belgian neutrality and the war began originally because of the threat posed to an anachronistic multi-national state called the Austro-Hungarian Empire by Balkan, and in particular Serbian, nationalism, but anyone who knows anything about the history would realise that with sufficient resolve diplomacy could have prevented the conflict. You see I was once a modern history student so I know about these things.
I feel really angry whenever I think about this war. I remember visiting a war memorial in Northern France a few years ago. I forget its name but I'll look it up. It began I think with a 'V'.
I was with a party of young Christians who had been holidaying in the Loire Valley in 2003 I seem to remember. I remember how angry I felt then at the appalling loss of life. How much of a who-ha there would be now. No government now would be allowed to get away with such losses as the combatants endured during that conflict.
Yet we are still fighting wars in far off places in countries which we scarcely understand still less really care about to make the world a safer place we are told. But are we, I ask. When has war ever really solved anything? It's said that allied vengeance towards Germany contributed towards the Second World War. Wars, like punch-ups in a school playground, often seem merely to increase rather than abate enmity. When will we ever learn, I ask?
Frankly, if it weren't for my faith I would despair of life. It makes me wonder how any thoughtful person remains cheerful with such a bleak history as this. Perhaps you could let me know your thoughts, whoever reads this.

4 comments:

duopastorale said...

I don't know much about history, but didn't the 2nd world war get rid of Hitler? Perhaps we would be speaking German if we had not fought him, and it's horrendous to think of the consequences for the Jews. I'm afraid that war is sometimes necessary in our fallen world where evil sometimes needs dealing with brute force.

I wonder what would happen if we 'loved our enemies' as Jesus commanded. Does this rule out war? Perhaps we shouldn't love our enemies at the expense of protecting our friends.

Interesting post :)

Suz. said...

Well, Steve, I've had your questions in my mind since reading them. If one doesn't have a ready opinion, one doesn't want to answer such questions half-heartedly (which can often describe much of the blogosphere).

A quote in a book I started reading today resonated with your questions. It is from the introduction (by John Swinton) to the book (Living Gently in a Violent World, by Stanley Hauerwas and Jean Vanier). Swinton noted the irony that "we constantly seek peace by going to war."

I am reminded of the biblical words "Seek peace and pursue it." I think war should only be an option when all other efforts of diplomacy and peacemaking are exhausted.

Steve said...

The Second World War certainly got rid of Hitler, Mike, but might not have been necessary at all if we had approached peace after the first more intelligently and less vengefully, but it's easy to be rational now. In 1918 the anger generated by all the loss of life led to calls to 'Hang the Kaiser' and 'Make Germany pay'. Understandable, but not the way to secure peace in the longer term and, of course, not very Christian, if we think on the words of our Lord about forgiving our enemies. It shows how far we all are from observing His commands.

Wanda said...

Unfortunately, wars have always been and always will....The O.T. is full of wars....and the N.T says we will have them until the King of Kings come to reigh forever... In this world we will have trouble...But HE has overcome the world.

I don't take war lightly.... I hate the loss of life...But I know the end of the story... and that is where I find my peace and joy!

Love your thoughtful article... keep ranbling, Steve...keep ranbling.

LOL:Wanda